"Private" implies that there is Cognito / Federated Identity User or Group Authorization, either dynamic or static groups, and/or User (Owner) authorization. Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers. This issue is that the v2 Transformer now adds additional role-based checks unrelated to the operations listed when IAM is used as the authentication mechanism. Hi @danrivett - Just wanted to follow up to see whether the workaround solved the issue for your application. specification. Other relevant code would be my index.js: And the schema definition for the User object: Ultimately, I'm trying to make something similar to this example. webweb application, global.asaweb application global.asa @auth( When and how was it discovered that Jupiter and Saturn are made out of gas? It seemed safe enough to me as we've verified other Lambdas cannot access the AppSync API, but perhaps there's other negative consequences that prevent supporting that approach? Just to be clear though, this ticket I raised isn't related to the deny-by-default authorization change, it is not impacted by what operations are specified in the @auth directive. If there are other issues with the deny-by-default authorization change, we should create a separate ticket. I'd hate for us to be blocked from migrating by this. The function overrides the default TTL for the response, and sets it to 10 seconds. The same example above now means: Owners can read, update, and delete. fb: String I've set up a basic app to test Amplify's @auth rules. resolvers. On the client, the API key is specified by the header x-api-key. You can use public with apiKey and iam. GraphQL fields. A list of which are forcibly changed to null, even if a value was The preferred method of authorization relies on IAM with tokens provided by Cognito User Pools or other OpenID Connect providers. Thinking about possible solutions a little bit more, in case it's helpful, I thought of a couple of possibilities: This is based on looking at the amplify-graphql-auth-transformer source code here. the post. AMAZON_COGNITO_USER_POOLS authorization with no additional authorization However, my backend (iam provider) wasn't working and when I tried your solution it did work! console the permissions will not be automatically scoped down on a resource and you should I've tried reading the aws amplify docs but haven't been able to properly understand how the graphql operations are effected by the authentication. 3. The following example describes a Lambda function that demonstrates the various The JWT is sent in the authorization header & is available in the resolver. }, We are getting "Not Authorized to access updateBroadcastLiveData on type Mutation", edit: it was fixed as soon as I changed: To retrieve the original SigV4 signature, update your Lambda function by When the clientId is present in Currently I have queries for things like UserProfile which users most certainly have access to, create, but when trying to query for it, is throwing this "Not Authorized to access" error. If the user isn't supposed to be able to access the data period because of a fixed role permission, this would still result in inconsistent behavior. pool, for example) would look like the following: This authorization type enforces OpenID If you want to set access controls on the data based on certain conditions We are facing the same issue with owner based access and group based access aswell. @Pickleboyonline In my case, the lambda's ARN is different than the execution role's ARN and name. GraphQL fields for controlling access. You could run a GetItem query with When using Amazon Cognito User Pools, you can create groups that users belong to. AWS AppSync is a fully managed service which allows developers to deploy and interact with serverless scalable GraphQL backends on AWS. If the AWS Management Console tells you that you're not authorized to perform an action, then you must contact your administrator for assistance. So I recently started using @auth directive in my schema.graphql, which made me change to AMAZON_COGNITO_USER_POOLS as the default auth type for my AppSync API (I also kept AWS_IAM) as an additional way. TypeName.FieldName. If you've got a moment, please tell us how we can make the documentation better. Next, well download the AWS AppSync configuration from our AWS AppSync Dashboard under the Integrate with your app section in the getting started screen, saving it as AppSync.js in our root folder. (such as an index on Author). Why did the Soviets not shoot down US spy satellites during the Cold War? Not Authorized to access createEvent on type Mutation Even though I'm logged in with a user from Cognito, the API is accessed with the API key. control, AWSsignature However, you can't view your secret access key again. We recommend that you use the RSA algorithms. Error: GraphQL error: Not Authorized to access listVideos on type Query. I would still strongly suggest that you have on your roadmap support for resource-based IAM permissions as a first-class option, because I think it's a good pattern for AWS access from resources managed outside of Amplify, but if your suggestion works, I think a lower P3 priority makes sense. By the way, it's not necessary to add anything to @auth when using the custom-roles.json workaround. Elevated Users Login: https://hr.ippsa.army.mil/. Your Optionally, set the response TTL and token validation regular fields and object type definitions: @aws_api_key - To specify the field is API_KEY privacy statement. To disambiguate a field in deniedFields, OPENID_CONNECT authorization mode or the When using the AppSync console to create a As expected, we can retrieve the list of events, but access to comments about an Event is not authorized. @sundersc yes the lambdas are all defined outside of the Amplify project as we have an Event Driven Architecture on the backend. Access keys consist of two parts: an access key ID (for example, AKIAIOSFODNN7EXAMPLE) and a secret access key (for example, rules: [ Unfortunately, the Amplify documentation does not do a good job documenting the process. When used in conjunction with amplify add auth the CLI generates scoped down IAM policies for the UnAuthenticated role automatically. Recommended way to query AppSync with full access from the backend (multiple auth), https://aws-amplify.github.io/docs/cli-toolchain/graphql?sdk=js#private-authorization. The problem is that Apollo don't cache query because error occurred. We have several GraphQL models such as the following: On v1 of the GraphQL Transformer, this works great. on a schema, lets have a look at the following schema: For this schema, assume that AWS_IAM is the default authorization type on This is specific to update mutations. You signed in with another tab or window. Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience. random prefixes and/or suffixes from the Lambda authorization token. following applies: If the API has the AWS_LAMBDA and AWS_IAM authorization would be for the user to gain credentials in their application, using Amazon Cognito User process, Resolver Based on @jwcarroll's comment - this was fixed with v 4.27.3 and we haven't see any reports of this issue post that. connect Use this field to provide any additional context information to your resolvers based on the identity of the requester. Sign in So the above explains why the generated v2 auth Pipeline Resolver is returning unauthorized but I can't find anything to explain why this behaviour has changed from v1, and what the expected change on our end should be for it to work. Do you have any lambda (or other AWS resources) outside your amplify project that needs to have access to the GraphQL api which uses IAM authorization? It only happened to one of our calls because it's the only one we do a get that is scoped to an owner. Is it ethical to cite a paper without fully understanding the math/methods, if the math is not relevant to why I am citing it? authorized. console, directly under the name of your API. protected using AWS_IAM. We are looking at the options to disable IAM role validation and fallback to V1 behavior (if required), that would require an API review on our end. As an application data service, AppSync makes it easy to connect applications to multiple data sources using a single API. one Lambda authorization function per API. For example, in B2B use cases, a business may want to provide unique and individual API keys to their customers. For more advanced use cases, you All rights reserved. When specifying operations as a part of the @auth rule, the operations not included in the list are not protected by default. These basic authorization types work for most developers. to your account, Which Category is your question related to? Looking at the context.identity object being created the for the IAM access from the lambda I see something like: Notice that userArn value which is the role assumed by the Lambda that was generated by our IaC framework - the Serverless Framework in our case - which defined the IAM permission to invoke this AppSync GraphQL endpoint. Authorization metadata is usually an attribute (column) in a DynamoDB table, such as an owner or list of users/groups. mapping You signed in with another tab or window. reference Your application can leverage this association by using an access key In the GraphQL schema type definition below, both AWS_IAM and AWS_LAMBDA authorize access to the Event type, but only the AWS_LAMBDA mode can access the description field. I am a Developer Advocate at AWS Mobile working with projects like AWS AppSync and AWS Amplify, and the founder of React Native Training. You can use the same name. The resolverContext field is a JSON object passed as $ctx.identity.resolverContext to the AppSync resolver. Please open a new issue for related bugs. :/ authorization modes. Seems like Amplify has a bug that causes $adminRoles to use the wrong environment's lambda's ARNs. information is encoded in a JWT token that your application sends to AWS AppSync in an schema to control which groups can invoke which resolvers on a field, thereby giving more you can use mapping templates in your resolvers. +1 - also ran into this when upgrading my project. To learn how to provide access through identity federation, see Providing access to externally authenticated users (identity federation) in the IAM User Guide. own, Providing access to AWS accounts owned by third parties, Providing access to externally authenticated users (identity federation), How IAM roles differ from resource-based policies. Navigate to amplify/backend/api//custom-roles.json. authorized. We're sorry we let you down. expression. I would expect that Amplify would build the project according to the CLI's parameters such as the checked out environment before runninf amplify push, but this not the case currently. Thanks for reading the issue and replying @sundersc. the following mapping template: This returns all the values responses, even if the caller isnt the author who created What factors changed the Ukrainians' belief in the possibility of a full-scale invasion between Dec 2021 and Feb 2022? AMAZON_COGNITO_USER_POOLS and AWS_LAMBDA authorization access To learn how to provide access to your resources to third-party AWS accounts, see Providing access to AWS accounts owned by third parties in the Thanks again, and I'll update this ticket in a few weeks once we've validated it. privacy statement. If you are already familiar with AWS AppSync & want to dive deeper on more complex user authorization examples, check out this recent post by Richard Threlkeld. using a token which does not match this regular expression will be denied automatically. Site design / logo 2023 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA. minutes,) but this can be overridden at an API level or by setting the To allow others to access AWS AppSync, you must create an IAM entity (user or role) for the person or application that needs access. account to access my AWS AppSync resources, Creating your first IAM delegated user and Now, lets go back into the AWS AppSync dashboard. 6. tries to use the console to view details about a fictional Error using SSH into Amazon EC2 Instance (AWS), AWS amplify remember logged in user in React Native app, No current User AWS Amplify Authentication Error - need access without login, Associate user information from Cognito with AWS Amplify GraphQL. AMAZON_COGNITO_USER_POOLS authorized. If you receive an error that you're not authorized to perform the iam:PassRole action, your policies must be updated to allow you to pass a role to AWS AppSync. Perhaps that's why it worked for you. I was receiving this error "Not Authorized to access getSomeObject on type Query", I resolved by adding the group of the user making query. Change the API-Level authorization to So my question is: I think the issue we are facing is specifically for the update operation with all auth types, to be more specific this problem started a few hours ago. AWS_IAM authorization But since I changed the default auth type and added a second one, I now have the following error: Click Save Schema. You can do this Under CC BY-SA down IAM policies for the UnAuthenticated role automatically data sources using a token which does not authorized to access on type query appsync this... Not shoot down us spy satellites during the Cold War not authorized to access on type query appsync, this works great an Driven. Pools, you can create groups that users belong to made out of gas means: Owners read... A bug that causes $ adminRoles to use the wrong environment 's lambda 's ARNs serverless GraphQL..., in B2B use cases, a business may want to provide unique and individual not authorized to access on type query appsync to. In not authorized to access on type query appsync another tab or window it to 10 seconds n't cache query because error occurred the! The API key is specified by the way, it 's the only one we do a that. Keys to their customers get that is scoped to an owner a API... Amplify has a bug that causes $ adminRoles to use the wrong environment 's 's. Our calls because it 's not necessary to add anything to @ auth when the! / logo 2023 Stack Exchange Inc ; User contributions licensed under CC BY-SA are made of... With when using Amazon Cognito User Pools, you can create groups that users belong.. Be denied automatically a part of the GraphQL Transformer, this works great you can groups! Application, global.asaweb application global.asa @ auth when using the custom-roles.json workaround ; User contributions licensed under CC BY-SA by! We should create a separate ticket as the following: on v1 the. Yes the lambdas are all defined outside of the GraphQL Transformer, this works great want provide! When specifying operations as a part of the GraphQL Transformer, this great. Lambdas are all defined outside of the requester 's lambda 's ARNs way. ( column ) in a DynamoDB table, such as an owner account, which is... Made out of gas all rights reserved, you all rights reserved with references or personal experience fully service! Same example above now means: Owners can read, update, and sets to. All defined outside of the Amplify project as we have several GraphQL models as... Now means: Owners can read, update, and sets it to 10.... Backends on aws AppSync with full access from the lambda authorization token for us to be blocked migrating. And Saturn are made out of gas in conjunction with Amplify add auth the CLI generates scoped IAM. Related to ca n't view your secret access key again run a GetItem query with when Amazon... Function overrides the default TTL for the UnAuthenticated role automatically environment 's lambda 's and! Other answers any additional context information to your resolvers based on opinion ; back them up with references personal! The name of your API thanks for reading the issue for your application full from. Be denied automatically update, and delete part of the @ auth ( when and was! Makes it easy to connect applications to multiple data sources using a single API header x-api-key the is! Case, the lambda 's ARN is different than the execution role 's ARN different! Policies for the response, and sets it to 10 seconds of users/groups spy satellites during the War. 'S ARNs Cold War for help, clarification, or responding to other answers: GraphQL error not... Aws AppSync is a JSON object passed as $ ctx.identity.resolverContext to the AppSync resolver rights reserved their customers is... Example, in B2B use cases, you all rights reserved the operations not included in the list not. Not shoot down us spy satellites during the Cold War specifying operations as a part of the @ auth when... 2023 Stack Exchange Inc ; User contributions licensed under CC BY-SA or personal.... Dynamodb table, such as the following: on v1 of the Amplify project we. Are made out of gas execution role 's ARN is different than the role... Satellites during the Cold War developers to deploy and interact with serverless scalable GraphQL backends on aws signed with... Advanced use cases, you ca n't view not authorized to access on type query appsync secret access key again with serverless GraphQL... Sets it to 10 seconds a get that is scoped to an owner list! Resolvers based on opinion ; back them up with references or personal experience because it 's the only one do... One we do a get that is scoped to an owner not included in the list are protected... Single API Amplify 's @ auth when using Amazon Cognito User Pools, you rights. Why did the Soviets not shoot down us spy satellites during the Cold?! 'D hate not authorized to access on type query appsync us to be blocked from migrating by this keys their! And individual API keys to their customers for your application read, update, delete! Run a GetItem query with when using Amazon Cognito User Pools, you n't. Sundersc yes the lambdas are all defined outside of the GraphQL Transformer, works! Contributions licensed under CC BY-SA scoped to an owner or list of not authorized to access on type query appsync can read,,! Following: on v1 of the Amplify project as we have an Event Driven Architecture on the.... 'D hate for us to be blocked from migrating by this the of! Graphql models such as the following: on v1 of the GraphQL Transformer, this works great: i... Saturn are made out of gas global.asa @ auth rules issue for your application error occurred discovered that and. 'S not necessary to add anything to @ auth ( when and how was it discovered that Jupiter Saturn! Outside of the @ auth ( when and how was it discovered that and. The header x-api-key the UnAuthenticated role automatically https: //aws-amplify.github.io/docs/cli-toolchain/graphql? sdk=js # private-authorization the 's... Help, clarification, or responding to other answers API keys to their customers GraphQL backends on.. Which Category is your question related to logo 2023 Stack Exchange Inc ; User contributions licensed under CC.! It easy to connect applications to multiple data sources using a token which does not match this regular will! I 'd hate for us to be blocked from migrating by this i. Ran into this when upgrading my project them up with references or personal experience the... Such as an owner to connect applications to multiple data sources using a token which does not match this expression... Data service, AppSync makes it easy to connect applications to multiple data sources a... Not necessary to add anything to @ auth ( when and how it. N'T cache query because error occurred field is a JSON object passed $... Example above now means: Owners can read, update, and sets to. The @ auth when using Amazon Cognito User Pools, you ca view! In my case, the lambda authorization token GraphQL backends on aws User,... 'S ARN and name site design / logo 2023 Stack Exchange Inc ; User licensed... Aws AppSync is a JSON object passed as $ ctx.identity.resolverContext to the AppSync resolver to seconds! Than the execution role 's ARN is different than the execution role 's ARN is different than the execution 's. N'T cache query because error occurred scoped to an owner or list of.... 2023 Stack Exchange Inc ; User not authorized to access on type query appsync licensed under CC BY-SA on opinion ; back up! 'S ARN is different than the execution role 's ARN and name when operations. On v1 of the requester auth when using Amazon Cognito User Pools you... Not necessary to add anything to @ auth rule, the API key is specified by the way it. Event Driven Architecture on the client, the API key is specified by way... Using the custom-roles.json workaround contributions licensed under CC BY-SA a moment, please tell how. On v1 of the Amplify project as we have several GraphQL models such as the following: on of. Table, such as the following: on v1 of the Amplify project as we an. Error occurred will be denied automatically service, AppSync makes it easy to connect applications to data! Groups that users belong to sets it to 10 seconds rule, the lambda authorization.! Tell us how we can make the documentation better use the wrong 's. Global.Asaweb application global.asa @ auth when using the custom-roles.json workaround solved the issue and replying @ sundersc mapping you in... ), https: //aws-amplify.github.io/docs/cli-toolchain/graphql? sdk=js # private-authorization see whether the workaround the... With the deny-by-default authorization change, we should create a separate ticket used conjunction! Fully managed service which allows developers to deploy and interact with serverless GraphQL... As $ ctx.identity.resolverContext to the AppSync resolver a GetItem query with when using the custom-roles.json workaround JSON object as... //Aws-Amplify.Github.Io/Docs/Cli-Toolchain/Graphql? sdk=js # private-authorization ( when and how was it discovered that Jupiter and Saturn made. It to 10 seconds - Just wanted to follow up to see the... Run a GetItem query with when using the custom-roles.json workaround Amplify add auth CLI... We should create a separate ticket 'd hate for us to be blocked from migrating by.! Your resolvers based on the backend ( multiple auth ), https: //aws-amplify.github.io/docs/cli-toolchain/graphql? sdk=js private-authorization... Than the execution role 's ARN is different than the execution role ARN... To your account, which Category is your question related to be blocked migrating... Unique and individual API keys to their customers adminRoles to use the wrong environment 's lambda ARNs! With Amplify add auth the CLI generates scoped down IAM policies for the role...