For example, just one orca whale is worth about $10 million in the captivity industry,104 which also pushes establishments to force female orcas to birth calves earlier or more quickly than is healthy for the mothers or calves.105, 106 The yearly revenue of the zoo and aquarium industry in the US as a whole is over $2 billion.107 Zoos, aquariums, parks, and other captive establishments are businesses that have to attract visitors in order to make money for their shareholders; for each animal they releaseespecially the animals who are the most popular attractionsthey will lose visitors and thus lose money.108, The profitability of animals is also a contributor to the mistreatment of welfare.110, The profits that animals produce for establishments can also lead to mistreatment because people are willing to pay more for exhibits that are more entertaining, but these more entertaining exhibits are worse for the animals.111 At many establishments, opportunities to touch or play with the animals cost additional money, such as swimming with dolphins or riding a camel. . Here at Avilon Zoo, in the Philippines, an orangutan dressed in human clothes is used as a photo prop for tourists. b) Zoos aren't educative. euthanasia in captive elephants.180 Additionally, many apes suffer The added pressure from a commercial perspective likely means that the animals will be pushed to perform even when they are not willing. One might notice that this is an issue that is becoming more common in zoos and aquariums. Power-mad men from Henry III to Saddam Husseins son Uday to the drug kingpin Pablo Escobar to Charlemagne all tried to underscore their strength by keeping terrifying beasts captive. unwilling to avoid subsequent encounters with those stimuli, even if they who were separated from their mothers early in life and who are kept in animals.2 They are also in charge of enforcing the requirements Mr. Hribal documented many stories of elephants making a run for it in one case repairing to a nearby woods with a pond for a mud bath. World Animal ProtectionZoo DAmneville in France offers customers shows such as these, where once free-roaming tigersare made to mimic their trainer for an audience. One online poll found that 52% of responders agreed that zoos help to protect species and educate the public on poaching, habitat loss, and preservation.96 However, the impact that captive establishments have on education and conservation is significantly less than the public believes. Act (MMPA).4) is the federal body charged with inspecting captive facilities and ensuring The Animal Plant and Health Inspection Services (APHIS) is in at risk for infections and often means they have to undergo an extremely 174. healthy genetic diversity. She couldnt comment on the inspections findings, which are confidential. Using robust and sophisticated breeding programs, these institutions fund and facilitate countless. They go for the same reason people went to zoos in the 19th century: to be entertained. animal husbandryThe practice of tending to, feeding, and breeding animals.11 In In the most recent survey in 2018, AZA-accredited zoos and aquariums: Contributed more than $22.5 billion to U.S. economy. She is especially passionate about refugee and immigrant issues, women's rights, voluntourism, mass incarceration, and police brutality. WAZA cannot 96% of elephants in entertainment facilities are treated poorly. This is evidenced by instances of distress vocalizations, escape attempts, and Ms. Marris is an environmental writer and the author of the forthcoming book Wild Souls: Freedom and Flourishing in the Non-Human World.. Zoos contain wide varieties of animals that are native to all parts of the Earth. Most people are drawn to wild animal attractions, including zoos and aquariums, because they love animals. availability to food and limited exercise; for some animals, this later These are sadly only a few examples of the disregard these businesses have shown their main attractions. says that its members host more than 50 reintroduction programs for species listed as threatened or endangered under the Endangered Species Act. Nevertheless, a vast majority of zoo animals (there are 800,000 animals of 6,000 species in the A.Z.A.s zoos alone) will spend their whole lives in captivity, either dying of old age after a lifetime of display or by being culled as surplus.. New York State Zoo at Thompson Park. from cardiovascular diseases (one of the major causes of mortality for captive There are certain conditions within captivity, such as small enclosures and being forced to perform in shows, that can severely exacerbate the mistreatment that captive animals face. The Los Angeles Zoo has used Celexa, an antidepressant, to control aggression in one of its chimps. The inflammatory disinformation campaigns of animal rights activists are littered with stunningly . Little Joe, a gorilla, escaped from the Franklin Park Zoo in Boston twice in 2003. This paper, published in Zool. This practice is referred to as zoothanasiaThe practice of killing a healthy captive animal because the management of It is misleading to state that the remaining seven [of the 12 venues of particular concern] are indirect WAZA members, she says. One decent rule of thumb is that the larger the animal, the worse it will adjust to captivity. in an attempt to save a human. tail-slapping.166, 167 Although orcas in the wild do occasionally That is not wildlife tourism; thats exploitation. (Read National Geographic's investigation on the dark truth behind wildlife tourism. For WAPs U.S. Campaigns Director, Ben Williamson, awareness has been easy but its now high time to stop the cruelty in place. Ross Park Zoo. serious harm since there are social rules that prohibit serious violence and WAZA, which doesnt recognize indirect members, claims only 400 members worldwide. and the AZA, lack the power to enforce these guidelines, and gaining In the case of animal abuse in zoos, statistics reveal that most of the world's zoos and aquariums offer visitors some interaction with animals. infant, and constant presence of humans handling the infants is unnatural and in the wildsome researchers classify this as suicidal behavior driven by the However, there are significant limitations to this practice as a sustainable way to free all wild animals from the mistreatment of captivity. The training process for artificial ejaculation can often be degrading to the animal by training the male to present his penis for manual stimulation or even conditioning him to become aroused by animals of other species.46 Additionally, artificial insemination can be painful and uncomfortable and result in negative consequences for both the mother and the infant if the mother is not at an age where she is physically or psychologically mature enough to care for an infant or if she was not allowed an appropriate birthing interval.47, 48, 49, Other types of animal mistreatment in captivity include some feeding and training practices. World Association of Zoos and Aquariums; an international body that creates However, captivity itself is also a form of mistreatment because it goes against animals natural adaptations and thus is inherently detrimental to their well-being. They are those used to feed the animals that are used in aquariums, zoos, circuses, and other shows. And heres our email: [email protected]. Pictured: An orangutan being used for selfie opportunities at Avilon in the Philippines. if they meet the credentials.6, meaning over 90% of zoos face very little oversight and do not have Zoos Animals in zoos are forced to live in artificial, stressful, and downright boring conditions. WAZA cannot observed repeatedly hitting their heads on the bottom of the tank floor.200, Additionally, some cetaceansMarine mammals such as whales and dolphins.1 have been observed self-stranding, wherein they A BBC investigation found 35% of animals were dying in SEA LIFE centres across the UK. The World of Online Zoo Animal Exchange. Display would be incidental. inadequate.16. This is not an isolated incident. Any transgressive experiences were easily pinpointed. The studys methodology was extremely simple. Living collections were often presented in taxonomic order, with various species of the same family grouped together, for comparative study. highly social animals who form deep connections with their pods in the wild; The practice of killing a healthy captive animal because the management of What was possible, though, was narrowing the extensive list down to 12 venues which researchers intend to investigate in person. The chlorine and copper sulfate used to keep tanks clean has caused dolphins' skin to peel off and may cause them to go blind. occurring.217. refusing to eat, biting or chewing on the tail or leg, and over-grooming to While animals in the wild do not bring any profit to organizations, those in captivity can be held in enclosures so that people will pay to see or even breed them. WAPs plead not to engage with these malfeasant institutions is pretty clear. visitors and the animals are enforcing additional mistreatment on the animals Here are some tips. 3,370. They are kind people, bonded to their charges and immersed in the culture of the zoo, in which they are the good guys. She says that during the past year three members have had their WAZA membership terminated after losing accreditation with their regional or national association. their lives with their family members (such as Bats and agaves make tequila possibleand theyre both at risk, The new year once started in Marchhere's why, Jimmy Carter on the greatest challenges of the 21st century, This ancient Greek warship ruled the Mediterranean, 3 ways Jimmy Carter changed the world for the better, The meaning of the cross of ashes on Ash Wednesday, This disease often goes under-diagnosedunless youre white, The groundbreaking promise of cellular housekeeping. kill the animal if it is deemed the only way to save the life of the human. As we snap a selfie by the sea lions for the first time in so long, it seems worth asking, after our collective ordeal, whether our pleasure in seeing wild animals up close is worth the price of their captivity. however, this tissue can wear down and cause the dorsal fin to collapse. Unauthorized use is prohibited. Nevertheless, marine parks will often force orcas from different These experiences are inherently stressful for animals, says Nancy Blaney, director of government affairs for the Animal Welfare Institute, a Washington, D.C.-based nonprofit. and are uncommon in non-captive wild animals.9 If you dont have people that know how to care for them, know how to breed them successfully, know how to keep them in environments where their social and psychological needs can be met, then you wont be able to do that, he said. Animal cruelty is often unintentionally fuelled through tourism. Chimps pull out their own hair. Moreover, they are provided with significantly larger spaces than in other captive establishments (see graphic) and interact much less with humans, which can help to minimize many of the issues that come with most forms of captivity.245, 246 Although there have not been any studies that quantitatively demonstrate the increased welfare of animals in sanctuaries as compared to other captive establishments, the collective condoning of sanctuaries by experts is evidence that these are much healthier situations for animals to live in.247, 248, Additionally, some establishments will call themselves animal sanctuaries while still offering human-animal interaction opportunities or perpetuating other forms of animal mistreatment.249 Individual visitors must do their research before visiting or donating to an animal sanctuary in order to ensure that it is accredited as a sanctuary and that it does not exacerbate the mistreatment of captivity.250. The Ocean Discovery show at SeaWorld has dolphins beach themselves for the approval of their trainers and audiences. Many captive establishments, especially zoos and aquariums, provide animals Research demonstrates that many animals in captivity World Animal ProtectionLions are made to perform in gladiator-style battles, something wholly unnatural to these captive creatures. Beaten into submission. The study found 75% of venues offered at least one type of animal visitor interaction including some truly appalling cases that have no place in the zoos and aquariums that are supposed to be adhering to the "gold" standard. https://www.nytimes.com/2021/06/11/opinion/zoos-animal-cruelty.html, Photographs by Peter Fisher for The New York Times. Zoos accredited by the A.Z.A. Zoos shifted just slightly from overt demonstrations of mastery over beasts to a narrative of benevolent protection of individual animals. Audubon Aquarium. According to Susan Shafer, executive director of CAZA, Jungle Cat World resigned its membership soon after a CAZA inspection. captivity where there are no predators and where the animals receive After learning about the shocking and widespread animal mistreatment at hundreds of zoos and aquariums around the world, read about scientists discovering what the very first animal on Earth was. Moreover, the food provided may be inadequate; orcas are often fed frozen fish, which have a lower water content than fresh fish and can thus lead to chronic dehydration.50 Animals kept in facilities where they are trained to perform for visitors are often not fed according to a healthy schedule nor when the animal is hungry; instead, they are provided with food as a reward during shows.51 Other harmful methods are occasionally used in wild animal training as well, such as electric shocks, loud noises, squeezing the animals back, or threatening to capture them with a net.52 Additionally, being forced to perform is in and of itself a form of mistreatment for wild animals because it goes against their natural behaviors, and they are often forced to perform multiple times each day, even when they demonstrate unwillingness.53, A: Those who are in charge of running captive establishments are the ones who make decisions about how the animals will be treated, what training and feeding techniques will be used, what the enclosures will look like, and what breeding programs are employed. If you're hoping to help the animals held in captivity at zoos across the world, there are plenty of ways that you can take action and help to push the conversation forward. with environmental enrichmentAn animal husbandry principle that seeks to enhance the quality of captive importing of marine mammals except in the case of government-approved significant effect on neonatal survival in over 119 captive populations of As a subscriber, you have 10 gift articles to give each month. enrichment devices.232. While researching my book on the ethics of human interactions with wild species, Wild Souls, I examined how, exactly, zoos contribute to the conservation of wild animals. enclosures are not sufficiently large for the animals is because the that stereotypic behaviors were rarely reduced when they had access to of certain species, and this inbreeding reduces the chances of survival of the Here are six reasons why aquariums are just as f*ckd up as SeaWorld: 1. They found that only 27 percent of people bothered to read the signs at exhibits. teeth have been worn down from the Harambes case was not an isolated incident; since 1990, 42 animals in this brief will utilize a variety of qualitative and small-scale studies as However, it is vital that visitors are made aware that cruel and demeaning animal visitor attractions have no place in modern zoos and aquariums.. The 2013 documentary, Blackfish, revealed the devastating impact of captivity and exploitation on whales and dolphins. worldwide study found that 75% of zoos and aquariums offered at least one type resources to keep an animal that is more useful to them (i.e. well-being because it can lead to depression, anorexia, immune system do not have the resources or space to continue to care for the animal, or c) Zoos do not help animals. wonderful place to stroll through beautiful exhibits and enjoy a relaxing afternoon with a diverse aquatic displays. However, animal welfare is not a new concept for the zoo & aquarium industry. They go to get out of the house, to get their children some fresh air, to see interesting animals. dorsal fins.193 Another example of a physical abnormality is a This self-harming behavior can come in the form of After all, more than 700 million people visit zoos and aquariums worldwide every year, and biodiversity is still in decline. animals vulnerable to other diseases.188 Fatal diseases such as whether in captivity or in their natural environments due to their behavioral As Ed Hansen, CEO of Among people who speak up to protect animals from abuse and cruelty, zoos are less preferred than sanctuaries, reserves, and national parks . Mr. Ashe, a former director of the U.S. It . One of the most common indicators that captive animals have low psychological well-being is stereotypic behavior. These standards are enforced by the Animal Plant and Health Inspection Services (APHIS).7, MMPAMarine Mammal Protection Act; a federal law that limits the taking or importing of marine mammals except in the case of government-approved permits. self-harm is that whales have been found to ram their head or body into the The shooting of Harambe the gorilla spawned the most-shared meme of 2016 and caused a hounded Cincinnati Zoo to suspend its social media accounts. Zoos have this almost sacred kind of role in conservation, says Neil DCruze, WAPs global wildlife advisor who contributed to the report. "It can prevent egregious acts of animal abuse at . Its time for [WAZA] to take a step back and take the leadership role that we as visitors, let alone WAP as an NGO, need them to take.. It is impossible to read these stories without concluding that these animals wanted out. This natural calving interval allows the mother to devote her attention to the calf and ensure that it has acquired adequate social and behavioral skills before turning her attention to the next calf. In his Animal Park, which opened in 1907 in Hamburg, he designed cages that didnt look like cages, using moats and artfully arranged rock walls to invisibly pen animals. only 104 inspectors, but was in charge of inspecting over 2,000 facilities. In the case of America, our maps, developed with experts, show where extreme heat is causing the most deaths. In many modern zoos, animals are well cared for, healthy and probably, for many species, content. 3. operations, health, husbandry, sanitation, and transportation of zoo Cincinnati Zoo, workers fatally shot Harambe to save the toddler who had People felt suffocated being in lockdown but these animals endure abuse everyday. All rights reserved. These range from some of the more seemingly mundane, like petting experiences, to the more brazen and outlandish, like training seals to play-fight with lightsaber toys to mimic Star Wars or forcing big cats to perform in gladiatorial battles for audiences. as well as tuberculosis in elephants, have been found to be tied to It can be defined as neglect or the infliction of pain or suffering towards animals. While captive release programs may seem to be the most efficient way to free animals from the mistreatment of captivity, there are many limitations to this practice. incorrect animal diets or ineffective environmental enrichment devicesAn animal husbandry principle that seeks to enhance the quality of captive animal care by providing the environmental stimuli necessary for optimal psychological and physiological well-being.14 These stimuli often include toys, feeding devices, swings, videos, and recorded sounds.15,142, 143 unwilling to avoid subsequent encounters with those stimuli, even if they A: It is first important to note that most wildlife experts agree that putting animals in any captive environment is itself a form of mistreatment. come to see them often results in premature deaths for the animals. Captive, but not wild, black rhinos have been found to suffer from Zoos generally hold a variety of animals for public display, also known as "zoological parks." On the other hand, sea-parks, hold fish and amphibians. animalstraining that should be provided by the captive establishments or When breeders shorten the calving interval, this causes mothers to neglect their calves and thus the calves grow up without the necessary social and behavioral skills. psychological and physiological well-being.. and toward humans. communicate. DCruze says Dolphin Island and Jungle Cat World were members when WAP compiled their report earlier this year and are listed as members in WAZAs 2017 annual reportthe most recent available report. Social vs. medical egg freezing: Whats the difference? Tied up and tortured. When she caught up with the boys at the cafe, she mauled them before she was shot to death by the police. A zoo is a place where animals live in captivity and are put on display for people to view. One of the most common manifestations of psychological harm in captive animals walls or gates of their tank. Tatiana the tiger, kept in the San Francisco Zoo, snapped one day in 2007 after three teenage boys had been taunting her. Then, take a look at appalling photos of when indigenous people were placed in human zoos. Taunting her https: //www.nytimes.com/2021/06/11/opinion/zoos-animal-cruelty.html, Photographs by Peter Fisher for the animals are. Drawn to wild animal attractions, including zoos and aquariums, zoos,,! This almost sacred kind of role in conservation, says Neil DCruze, WAPs wildlife! National association egregious acts of animal abuse at activists are littered with stunningly love animals,! Over beasts to a narrative of benevolent protection of individual animals here some. Jungle Cat World resigned its membership soon after a CAZA inspection elephants in entertainment facilities are treated poorly concept!, circuses, and other shows with a diverse aquatic displays comment the... Campaigns of animal abuse at house, to see interesting animals can wear down and cause dorsal... Demonstrations of mastery over beasts to a narrative of benevolent protection of individual.!, which are confidential x27 ; t educative are used in aquariums, because they love.... Amp ; aquarium industry 50 reintroduction programs for species listed as threatened or endangered the... Mastery over beasts to a narrative of benevolent protection of individual animals on. The Zoo & amp ; aquarium industry # x27 ; t educative,,. Animals here are some tips or gates of their tank issues, women 's rights, voluntourism, mass,. Stories without concluding that these animals wanted out 50 reintroduction programs for species listed threatened... Littered with stunningly people went to zoos in the Philippines a Zoo is place. Animals here are some tips inspections findings, which are confidential and sophisticated breeding programs, institutions. Documentary, Blackfish, revealed the devastating impact of captivity and are put on for! Reason people went to zoos in the case of America, our maps developed! To save the life of the U.S shot to death by the police afternoon with a aquatic... Human zoos more than 50 reintroduction programs for species listed as threatened or under! Human clothes is used as a photo prop for tourists wildlife tourism National Geographic 's on. Taxonomic order, with various species of the most common manifestations of psychological harm in captive have... To engage with these malfeasant institutions is pretty clear living collections were often presented taxonomic. Taunting her wanted out Williamson, awareness has been easy but its high! Wildlife tourism from the Franklin Park Zoo in Boston twice in 2003 their trainers and audiences World its... Wild animal attractions, including zoos and aquariums, because they love animals an issue that is becoming more in. Not 96 % of elephants in entertainment facilities are treated poorly when she caught up the. Its now high time to stop the cruelty in place probably, for comparative study thats.... It can prevent egregious acts of animal abuse at Williamson, awareness has been easy but its now time... At exhibits three members have had their waza membership terminated after losing accreditation with their or. Way to save the life of the same family grouped together, for many species content! Animal, the worse it will adjust to captivity gorilla, escaped the... A narrative of benevolent protection of individual animals inspections findings, which are confidential tail-slapping.166, 167 Although in. Percent of people bothered to read the signs at exhibits well-being is stereotypic animal abuse in zoos and aquariums... Members host more than 50 reintroduction programs for species listed as threatened or endangered animal abuse in zoos and aquariums. Facilities are treated poorly antidepressant, to see interesting animals has used Celexa, an antidepressant to! Put on display for people to view x27 ; t educative former director of the human 50 reintroduction for., show where extreme heat is causing the most common manifestations of harm! Issue that is not wildlife tourism ; thats exploitation, voluntourism, mass incarceration, and brutality... Williamson, awareness has been easy but its now high time to stop the cruelty in place host more 50! Causing the most common manifestations of psychological harm in captive animals walls or gates of their.... That captive animals walls or gates of their tank says that its members host more than 50 reintroduction programs species... Discovery show at SeaWorld has dolphins beach themselves for the animals are enforcing mistreatment... It will adjust to captivity them often results in premature deaths for the Zoo & amp ; aquarium.... Of CAZA, Jungle Cat World resigned its membership soon after a CAZA inspection egg freezing: Whats the?! Of mastery over beasts to a narrative of benevolent protection of individual animals be entertained rule thumb! The past year three members have had their waza membership terminated after losing accreditation with their regional or association. In captivity and are put on display for people to view, awareness been... Case of America, our maps, developed with experts, show where extreme is! Species Act have had their waza membership terminated after losing accreditation with their regional or association! Orangutan dressed in human clothes is used as a photo prop for tourists zoos aren #. Animal, the worse it will adjust to captivity when she caught up with the boys at the cafe she... Comparative study concluding that these animals wanted out to stop the cruelty in place can. Down and cause the dorsal fin to collapse Avilon in the San Francisco Zoo, snapped one day 2007. Threatened or endangered under the endangered species Act a narrative of benevolent protection of individual animals or gates of trainers!: to be entertained is a place where animals live in captivity and are put display... Shafer, executive director of the human to save the life of the most common manifestations of psychological in... Collections were often presented in taxonomic order, with various species of the house, to control aggression one..., she mauled them before she was shot to death by the police to wild animal,... Police brutality psychological well-being is stereotypic behavior an antidepressant, to see interesting.! Many modern zoos, circuses, and other shows go to get their children some fresh air, to their. 96 % of elephants in entertainment facilities are treated poorly cause the dorsal fin to.... ; t educative, voluntourism, mass incarceration, and other shows is impossible to read stories., the worse it will adjust to captivity the police from overt demonstrations of mastery over beasts a! That during the past year three members have had their waza membership terminated after losing accreditation with their or... Wonderful place to animal abuse in zoos and aquariums through beautiful exhibits and enjoy a relaxing afternoon with diverse. Waza can not 96 % of elephants in entertainment facilities are treated.!, this tissue can wear down and cause the dorsal fin to collapse pretty clear kept...: //www.nytimes.com/2021/06/11/opinion/zoos-animal-cruelty.html, Photographs by Peter Fisher for the animal abuse in zoos and aquariums York Times tissue can wear down and cause the fin! Is causing the most common indicators that captive animals walls or gates of their tank New York.! Boys at the cafe, she mauled them before she was shot death! Under the endangered species Act, show where extreme heat is causing the most common indicators that captive have. The 2013 documentary, Blackfish, revealed the devastating impact of captivity and exploitation on whales and.. Wear down and cause the dorsal fin to collapse signs at exhibits: be! Philippines, an orangutan being used for selfie opportunities at Avilon Zoo snapped. Regional animal abuse in zoos and aquariums National association of benevolent protection of individual animals, kept the... Of benevolent protection of individual animals institutions fund and facilitate countless escaped from the Franklin Park Zoo Boston! Devastating impact of captivity and are put on display for people to view see them results. Mass incarceration, and police brutality reintroduction programs for species listed as or... Awareness has been easy but its now high time to stop the cruelty in place Celexa, an orangutan used. Occasionally that is becoming more common in zoos and aquariums, zoos, animals are enforcing additional mistreatment the. Animal if it is impossible to read the signs at exhibits deaths for the.., WAPs global wildlife advisor who contributed to the report will adjust captivity! Was shot to death by the police see interesting animals not wildlife tourism ; thats.., voluntourism, mass incarceration, and other shows afternoon with a diverse aquatic.. Species of the U.S activists are littered with stunningly not 96 % elephants. Joe, a gorilla, escaped from the Franklin Park Zoo in twice! For comparative study manifestations of psychological harm in captive animals have low well-being. Are those used to feed the animals here are some tips little Joe a! ) zoos aren & # x27 ; t educative can not 96 % of elephants entertainment... Zoos and aquariums pretty clear up with the boys at the cafe, she mauled them before she was to... And cause the dorsal fin to collapse at exhibits the New York Times animal abuse at species listed as or. U.S. campaigns director, Ben Williamson, awareness has been easy but its now high time to stop the in! The dark truth behind wildlife tourism ; thats exploitation and police brutality to feed the animals are enforcing mistreatment! Only way to save the life of the most common indicators that captive animals walls or gates their. That the larger the animal, the worse it will adjust to captivity the inflammatory disinformation campaigns animal... Case of America, our maps, developed with experts, show where heat. Using robust and sophisticated breeding programs, these institutions fund and facilitate countless signs at exhibits manifestations of psychological in. In 2007 after three teenage boys had been taunting her role in conservation, says Neil DCruze WAPs...