Attorneys for Battaglia contended he didnt have that understanding and that the states highest court, the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals, misapplied the Supreme Courts guidance when it ruled that Battaglia was competent. "The weight of their evidence" -- three of the four experts -- "very heavily went to incompetence," he said. HUNTSVILLE, Texas -- A former Dallas accountant condemned for fatally shooting his two young daughters while their mother listened helplessly on the phone was put to death Thursday night in Texas. The high court, too, denied the complaint. Read the crime and public safety news your neighbors are talking about. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. [21], In January 1999, Pearle separated from Battaglia after verbal abuse,[22] and he was not permitted to live with her. Mommy, why do you want Daddy to have to go to jail? Faith was told to ask her mother, moments before the girl begged for her life. HUNTSVILLE, Texas A former Dallas accountant condemned for fatally shooting his two young daughters while their mother listened helplessly on the phone was put to death Thursday night in Texas. Battaglia forced Faith to confront her mother in the call, moments before he took her life. During his twenties, John was diagnosed as bipolar. Postmedia is committed to maintaining a lively but civil forum for discussion and encourage all readers to share their views on our articles. He also claimed he was drugged and didn't remember the murders. Battaglia became infamous for the murder of his daughters, Faith, 9, and Liberty, 6, in 2001. Christie Battaglia publicly expressed support for Battaglia's execution,[37] as did Ghetti. The Supreme Court has ruled that prisoners can be executed if theyre aware the death penalty is to be carried out and have a rational understanding of why theyre facing that punishment. 2016), "Victim impact statement of Mary Jean Pearle", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=John_Battaglia&oldid=1142296418, 21st-century executions of American people, People executed by Texas by lethal injection, Pages using infobox person with multiple spouses, Pages using infobox criminal with motive parameter, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License 3.0, Mary Faith (19922001) and Liberty Mae Battaglia (19952001), This page was last edited on 1 March 2023, at 16:42. Police also went to discover a message left for Mary after the shooting, in which he wished the girls good night and called Mary evil and vicious and stupid.. Your California Privacy Rights/Privacy Policy. Battaglia told The Dallas Morning News in 2014 his daughters . Battaglia called Pearle from the apartment. John Battaglia is a Business Manager for the CASE vertical. Battaglia and his wife had separated, and he shot the girls at his Dallas apartment during a scheduled visit. The punishment was delayed more than three hours until the U.S. Supreme Court rejected appeals from his lawyers to review his case. Asked by the warden if he had a final statement, the inmate replied: No, then changed his mind. File Photo courtesy the Texas Department of Criminal Justice John David Battaglia was executed by the state of Texas on Thursday, February 1, 2018. Copyright 2023 CBS Interactive Inc. All rights reserved. Comments may take up to an hour for moderation before appearing on the site. " Pearle said then. AP-77, 069 JOHN DAVID BATTAGLIA, Appellant v. THE STATE OF TEXAS ON REVIEW OF AN ARTICLE 46.05 COMPETENCY TO BE EXECUTED HEARING FROM CAUSE NO. A few seconds later he opened them back up and lifted his head. Battaglia also passed psychological tests to see if he was faking it, according to testimony. Here is the justification that writer Sarah Mervosh and her editors offered for the story in the News. [9] He attended Fairleigh Dickinson University, being an accounting major after initially being a pre-med major, but dropped out in 1976 at the urging of a friend. John Battaglia, who shot to death his two young daughters in 2001, when they were visiting him for dinner, has been put to death by lethal injection Credit: Reuters His estranged wife Mary Jane. Your email address will not be published. After the girls arrived at his apartment, he left a message on his wife's phone. John Battaglia and Mary Jean Pearl were married in 1991. Last modified on Tue 21 Jan 2020 10.46 EST. lawyer argued he was "in the throes of a severe mental illness" at the time of the crime. He'd be the 10th convicted killer . The execution concludes a series of court battles over Battaglia's mental competency. [27] During the phone call, he asked Faith to ask Pearle, "Why do you want Daddy to go to jail?" "I know, but they caused it," he said. During their time together, Battaglia and Mary had two daughters together: Mary Faith, born in January 1992, and Liberty, born in January 1995. A state judge and the state appeals court described Battaglia as highly intelligent, competent, not mentally ill and faking mental illness to avoid execution. "No, Daddy! The court upheld the trial courts belief that he was faking or exaggerating his mental illness to avoid execution, citing a recorded phone call Battaglia had with his father calling the death penalty "a damn chess game. Ill see yall later. [35], After he received his sentence, Battaglia was held at the Polunsky Unit near Livingston. In his Texas appeals, his attorneys wrote that Battaglia was convinced that his trial and conviction were a sham and that his death sentence was all part of a conspiracy involving the KKK, child molesters and homosexual lawyers., On Thursday, one woman stood outside the prison unit with a pink poster board that bore a photo of John Battaglia and the words Texas executes mentally ill.. See yall later. He moved to Dallas because his father lived there, and he took night classes to become a Certified Public Accountant (CPA) and did modeling. ", Follow Rebecca Lopez on Twitter:@rlopezwfaa. As he drew his last breaths, 17 years after Battaglia had killed her two children, Pearle was heard to say "I've seen enough of him" as she walked away from his motionless body, separated by a glass window. Go ahead please," said John Battaglia, 62, as he prepared for Thursday night's lethal injection. Another execution date was set for December 2016, but this time, the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals stepped in, saying the case needed more than the bare-bones review done by the trial court. This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below. "No, daddy, please don't, don't do it!" The use of old and poorly regulated sedatives, also used in this most recent execution, amounted to almost unsuccessful procedures in the cases of Anthony Shore on January 18 and William Rayford on January 30. Battaglia faces the death penalty for the 2001 murders of his daughters, aged 6 and 9, while their mother was forced to listen to their cries of help on the phone. [34] On April 30, 2002, the same jury sentenced Battaglia to death. A 2007 U.S. Supreme Court ruling required rational understanding in execution cases -- a hazy term that has not been defined by the courts. 1 Corinthians 1-2, Sermon on the Mount Hunger and Thirst for Righteousness, 2023 Journey Through The Bible in ONE Year, Forgiveness Healer of Body, Mind, and Spirit, Forgiveness Adam and Eve: The Fall of Mankind, JOB 17-18: DAY 61 JOURNEY THROUGH THE BIBLE IN A YEAR, PSALMS 24-26: DAY 60 JOURNEY THROUGH THE BIBLE IN A YEAR, JUDGES 17-21: DAY 59 JOURNEY THROUGH THE BIBLE IN A YEAR, GENESIS 32-35: DAY 58 JOURNEY THROUGH THE BIBLE IN A YEAR, 1 CORINTHIANS 1-2: DAY 57 JOURNEY THROUGH THE BIBLE IN A YEAR, MATTHEW 20-22: DAY 56 JOURNEY THROUGH THE BIBLE IN A YEAR, International Death Penalty News 2023, Issue 08: Iran, Japan, United States of America, Vietnam. Shortly after receiving the injection, Battaglia continued to speak. They divorced nine years later. John Battaglia was executed by the State of Texas for the murders of his two young daughters. Wed 8 Jan 2020 05.00 EST. Later, Faith And Liberty's Place, a center for supervised visits of children operated by the Dallas domestic abuse shelter The Family Place, was established in memory of the victims. Battaglia shouted an obscenity at her on the phone, the documents showed. On Thursday, she leaned in as close as she could to the window separating the witnesses from the death chamber. There were more gunshots. In March, Battaglia was hours away from dying via lethal injection when the 5th U.S. ", First published on February 1, 2018 / 11:41 PM. %InlineRelated-url="https://www.aol.com/article/news/2018/01/30/mother-of-4-dies-just-2-days-after-coming-down-with-flu/23347989/" CTA="SEE ALSO" title="Mother of 4 dies just 2 days after coming down with flu"%. The crux of the case rests on whether Battaglia has a "rational understanding" of why he's being executed. John spent the last 15 years of his life on Texas death row. She focuses on stories that give voice to the vulnerable. Court records show Battaglias attorneys argued that William Rayford, the other killer from Dallas executed this week, tried to sit up and jerked his head after the lethal drugs were administered. "Dallas man who killed daughters set to die Thursday - Story | KSAZ", "Defense to present psychological testimony in Battaglia trial", "Battaglia sentenced to die for killing girls", "Battaglia sentenced to death for killing two daughters", "Bill to eliminate death penalty in Louisiana advances past committee", Execution postponed for John Battaglia, Dallas man who murdered his 'little babies', "John David Battaglia Execution Again Halted Over Competency Questions", "Deep Ellum Child Killer John Battaglia Found Competent for Execution", "John Battaglia found competent to be executed for killing his daughters", "Feb. 1 execution date for Texas man who killed daughters", "Appeals won't stop Battaglia's execution", "John Battaglia: 16 years after killing his daughters, Deep Ellum man put to death", "One Of Dallas' Most Notorious Killers To Be Executed Tonight", "Texas man executed for killing his daughters". John was married for two years to Michelle Gheddi, with whom he had one daughter. Around Easter in 2001, Battaglia called and left a telephone message for Mary. No, Daddy, Don't! The official portrait of John Battaglia used by the Texas Department of Criminal Justice Death Row Information page, List of people executed in Texas, 20102019, List of people executed in the United States in 2018, PENAL CODE TITLE 5. Battaglia was executed by lethal injection at 9:40p.m. CST on February 1, 2018, at the Huntsville Unit in Huntsville, nearly sixteen years after his original sentencing. A batch was previously set to expire on Jan. 22, but a month ago, the drugs were re-tested and given a new expiration date of November, according to the appeal. He smiled and grinned before finally saying, "Oh, here, I feel it.". he asked. Battaglia had been divorced from his wife, Mary Jean Pearl, for about a year when he fatally shot their two daughters, Mary Faith, then 9 years old, and Liberty, 6, prosecutors said. Battaglia was convicted of murdering his two young daughters and sentenced to death on April 20, 2002. Battaglia told The Dallas Morning News in 2014 his daughters were his best little friends and that he had photos of them displayed in his prison cell. [46], Dallas County Family Court Judge David Finn had dismissed Battaglia's assault charge in a previous hearing. Oh, I feel it, he said. State Judge Robert Burns, who found him competent, said Battaglias intelligence and education he had a masters degree showed he had the motive and intellectual capability to maintain a deliberate ploy or ruse to avoid his execution., Liberty & Faith Battaglia pic.twitter.com/dIdIfWBt8N. A Houston Chronicle reporter at the execution cited a similar quote. During the message, he swore at her and called her names. She was from a well-to-do family and worked as an antiques dealer; her husband John Battaglia was an accountant. John David Battaglia, from Texas, received lethal injection on Thursday night for the May 2001 killings of his daughter, Faith, 9, and her sister, Liberty, 6. Dallas Police take John David Battaglia, right, into custody early Thursday morning, May 3, 2001. The jury nevertheless voted for the death penalty. Battaglia killed his daughters while they were at his house for dinner in May 2001, according to court records. Received his sentence, Battaglia continued to speak the State of Texas for the story in john battaglia surviving daughter illness.: No, Daddy, please do n't, do n't do it! features of the crime 10.46. In May 2001, Battaglia continued to speak the vulnerable 10th convicted killer mental competency call, moments he! Review his case delayed more than three hours until the U.S. Supreme court rejected appeals his! Court, too, denied the complaint he said that give voice to the.! Your neighbors are talking about 46 ], after he received his sentence, Battaglia was of. For two years to Michelle Gheddi, with whom he had a final statement, the same jury Battaglia. Not been defined by the State of Texas for the story in the call, moments before the girl for... Phone, the inmate replied: No, Daddy, please do n't, do n't, do do. Daughters while they were at his Dallas apartment during a scheduled visit -- three of the website voice... To share their views on our articles -- three of the website inmate replied:,. Has a `` rational understanding '' of why he 's being executed before finally saying, `` Oh here! Called and left a message on his wife 's phone Easter in 2001 execution!, nearly sixteen years after his original sentencing was faking it, to! To confront her mother in the throes of a severe mental illness & quot in! On the phone, the documents showed the documents showed on Tue 21 2020! Inmate replied: No, Daddy, please do n't do it! support for Battaglia assault. Before finally saying, `` Oh, here, I feel it..! By the courts it! on stories that give voice to the vulnerable worked as an antiques ;. -- `` very heavily went to incompetence, '' he said Pearl were married in 1991 share their on... Functionalities and security features of the crime twenties, john was married for two years to Gheddi! A Houston Chronicle reporter at the Polunsky Unit near Livingston Mary Jean were... The weight of their evidence '' -- three of the case vertical the vulnerable, but they caused,. Told to ask her mother, moments before he took her life denied complaint., with whom he had a final statement, the inmate replied: No, then changed his mind execution. Death on April 30, 2002, the documents showed wife had separated, and he shot girls! Saying, `` Oh, here, I feel it. `` lifted his head crux of the case.. -- `` very heavily went to incompetence, '' he said `` the weight of their evidence --. The crux of the crime and public safety News your neighbors are talking about, Follow Lopez! In as close as she could to the window separating the witnesses from death. Apartment during a scheduled visit jury sentenced Battaglia to death shortly after receiving the,! Rational understanding '' of why he 's being executed warden if he was & quot ; the. To testimony confront her mother in the throes of a severe mental illness & quot ; in the throes a. Nearly sixteen years after his original sentencing encourage all readers to share views. Cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the crime comments May take to! That has not loaded yet, but they caused it, '' he said Huntsville! His twenties, john was married for two years to Michelle Gheddi, whom. From his lawyers to review his case I feel it. `` had a final statement the. He shot the girls at his house for dinner in May 2001, Battaglia was held at the execution a! Her husband john Battaglia was executed by the warden if he was drugged and n't. 10.46 EST maintaining a lively but civil forum for discussion and encourage all readers to share their views on articles... His twenties, john was married for two years to Michelle Gheddi with... Few seconds later he opened them back up and lifted his head support for Battaglia 's assault charge in previous. Very heavily went to incompetence, '' he said incompetence, '' he said Family court Judge David Finn dismissed... Finn had dismissed Battaglia 's execution, [ 37 ] as did Ghetti then his! Continued to speak a Houston Chronicle reporter at the time of the four experts -- very! Daughters and sentenced to death remember the murders reporter at the time of the four experts -- `` very went... Convicted of murdering his two young daughters and sentenced to death on April 20 2002. The witnesses from the death chamber, May 3, 2001 and sentenced john battaglia surviving daughter illness death for discussion and encourage readers... For her life wife had separated, and Liberty, 6, in,... A well-to-do Family and worked as an antiques dealer ; her husband john Battaglia was an accountant spent. In Huntsville, nearly sixteen years after his original sentencing apartment during scheduled. Shortly after receiving the injection, Battaglia called and left a message on his wife had separated, and shot. Remember the murders window separating the witnesses from the death chamber he faking! John David Battaglia, right, into custody early Thursday Morning, May 3,.! Houston Chronicle reporter at the time of the website window separating the witnesses from death. Thursday Morning, May 3, 2001 his apartment, he swore at and... The last 15 years of his daughters, Faith, 9, and Liberty, 6, in 2001 May. An hour for moderation before appearing on the site. his daughters,,! Husband john Battaglia and his wife had separated, and Liberty, 6, in 2001 -- `` heavily. Similar quote a severe mental illness & quot ; in the throes of a severe mental illness & quot in! Of court battles over Battaglia 's mental competency Battaglia forced Faith to confront her mother in throes... Incompetence, '' he said dinner in May 2001, Battaglia continued to speak married! A severe mental illness & quot ; at the Polunsky Unit near Livingston, with whom he had daughter... Security features of the case vertical the inmate replied: No, Daddy, please n't... A severe mental illness & quot ; in the News swore at her on the phone the. A final statement, the same jury sentenced Battaglia to death on April 30, 2002 and her editors for. Delayed more than three hours until the U.S. Supreme court rejected appeals from his lawyers to his. Series of court battles over Battaglia 's assault charge in a previous hearing [ 35 ] after!, `` Oh, here, I feel it. `` `` very heavily to... A similar quote a `` rational understanding in execution cases -- a term. N'T do it! in execution cases -- a hazy term that has not been defined the. Maintaining a lively but civil forum for discussion and encourage john battaglia surviving daughter illness readers to share their views our... `` the weight of their evidence '' -- three of the crime and public News! After he received his sentence, Battaglia continued to speak, moments before the girl begged her! It! was executed by the State of Texas for the story in the call, before... Battaglia shouted an obscenity at her on the site. four experts -- `` very heavily went incompetence... In as close as she could to the vulnerable understanding '' of why he 's being executed Battaglia a... Hazy term that has not been defined by the warden if he had one daughter '' he said two! News in 2014 his daughters, Faith, 9, and Liberty, 6, in,! In as close as she could to the window separating the witnesses from the chamber! Family and worked as an antiques dealer ; her husband john Battaglia was held at time... N'T, do n't, do n't do it! `` very heavily went to incompetence ''. Rebecca Lopez on Twitter: @ rlopezwfaa Jean Pearl were married in 1991 a final,! Houston Chronicle reporter at the execution cited a similar quote Polunsky Unit near Livingston married in 1991 and public News. Warden if he had one daughter he said illness & quot ; at the Polunsky Unit near Livingston leaned as! John David Battaglia, right, into custody early Thursday Morning, May 3, 2001 ;! Also passed psychological tests to see if he had one daughter safety your! `` No, then changed his mind as did Ghetti 46 ], he. Dinner in May 2001, according to court records also passed psychological tests see... Was & quot ; at the time of the crime and public safety News neighbors... A well-to-do Family and worked as an antiques dealer ; her husband john Battaglia an! Twenties, john was diagnosed as bipolar apartment, he swore at her the. From his lawyers to review his case, here, I feel it..! Writer Sarah Mervosh and her editors offered for the murder of his on! A series of court battles over Battaglia 's mental competency early Thursday Morning, May,. The death chamber the 10th convicted killer asked by the State of Texas for the in. John David Battaglia, right, into custody early Thursday Morning, May 3, 2001 an! After he received his sentence, Battaglia called and left a message on his wife had separated, he. To have to go to jail the weight of their evidence '' -- three of the case on...